These records come from Vol. 124, Miscellaneous Collected Records of the D.A.R., 1939-40, pages 477-481. Spellings and order of appearance are exactly as on the typescript. A copy of the original typescript is available for your personal viewing at three locations: the New York State Library in Albany, NY, the New York City Public Library (Research Library at 5th Ave. & 42nd St.), and the National D.A.R. Library in Washington, D.C.
ABOUT THESE RECORDS: The title of the original typescript referred to the "Methodist Church" only. However, both Rev. J.C.B. Moyer and Rev. Charles Eddy later served the Methodist Episcopal Church at Wolcott. Location of marriage ceremony wasn't stated, so these marriages may have been solemnized elsewhere than at the church or in East Palmyra. Several dates are out of sequence - all dates need to be confirmed through other sources. Interpretation of the ministers' handwritten records was by DAR member Mrs. Nellie T. Garlock, in October 1939 - numbers and spellings have been typed exactly as she interpreted them. "M." before several of the women's names means "Miss." Comments between "[ ]" are the typist's. The site coordinators would have no idea where the original records are in 2004, or if they still survive.
| Date | Name | Residence | Birthplace | Age |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Marriages by N.B. Randall | ||||
| 1875 May 1 | William Miller Miss Eliz. Heal | Rochester, N.Y. " " | | |
| 1874 June 15 | John Clark M. Sarah Bartron | Saltfleet, Wentworth Co. Ont. Canada Ridgeway, Welland Co., Canada | | 32 19 |
| 1875 June 12 | Henry C. Carpenter M. Helen Irish | Mereville, Erie Co., N.Y. " " | Mereville Colden, N.Y. | 19 [can't tell which person is age 19] |
| 1876 July 4 | Frank S. Mander M. Libby Rowley | Palmyra, Wayne Co., N.Y. " " | Palmyra " " | 28 25 |
| Marriages by Wm. H. Rogers | ||||
| 1876 Nov. 22 | Wm. R. Case Emma Hollister | Clifton Springs, N.Y. Near Port Gibson, N.Y. | | |
| 1877 Jan. 3 | Elias Burchard Jennie M. Fisk | Hopewell, Ont. Co., N.Y. E. Palmyra, N.Y. | | |
| 1877 Mar. 15 | Reuben Harding Laura A. Schimerhorn | Newark, N.Y. " " | England | 43 36 |
| 1877 May 5 | Abraham Wage Ella M. Gamble | Palmyra, N.Y. Marion, N.Y. | | |
| 1877 June 7 | George Ellis Harriet R. Edgingtin | Morton in the Marsh, Gloustershire, Eng. Longcompton, Warwickshire, Eng. | | |
| 1877 June 27 | Asaph Wood Ella J. Benham | Sanfrancisco, Calif. Chapinville, N.Y. | Peru, Clinton Co., N.Y. | |
| 1879 [date not stated] | Isaac Croucher Mrs. Axtell | Palmyra, N.Y. Second Marriage | | |
| 1879 Jan. 30 | Orlando Ostrander Sarah J. Fuller | Arcadia, N.Y. Newark, N.Y. | | |
| 1879 Mar. 27 | Adam H. Frey Katie E. Sauer | E. Palmyra, N.Y. Sodus, N.Y. | Waterloo, N.Y. Sodus, N.Y. | |
| 1879 Aug. 27 | James Sergeant Aurilia D. Sherman | Sodus, N.Y. Arcadia, N.Y. | Sodus, N.Y. | |
| 1880 Dec. 29 | Lewis E. Carroll Gene E. Tripp | Arcadia, N.Y. Marion, N.Y. | | |
| Marriages by Wm. J. Miller | ||||
| 1881 Feb. 1 | Samuel M. Deets Mattie L. Fisk | Port Gibson, N.Y. Newark, N.Y. | | |
| 1881 Apr. 16 | Wm. G. Lakey Adella M. Pullman | Palmyra, N.Y. " " | | |
| 1881 Oct. 2 | Hayes Ostrander Hattie Pierson | Newark, N.Y. " " | | |
| Marriages by J.C.B. Moyer | ||||
| 1883 Apr. 25 | Wesson N. Roblin Ella Harris | Palmyra, N.Y. E. Palmyra, N.Y. | | |
| 1883 Dec. 26 | John Byers Hattie E. Ratliff | Palmyra, N.Y. E. " " | Palmyra, N.Y. | |
| 1884 Jan. 8 | William Smith Mary F. Babcock | Shortsville, N.Y. Constantia, N.Y. | Canada Constantia, N.Y. | |
| 1884 June 28 | Gust Orlipp Ettie Calhoun | Palmyra, N.Y. " " | Plymouth, Wisc. Ontario, N.Y. | |
| Marriages by F.J. Whitney | ||||
| 1884 Dec. 31 | Charles W. Schwab Cora B. Aikin | Fairville, N.Y. Fairville, N.Y. | | |
| Marriages by Chas. Eddy | ||||
| 1886 July 31 | Charles A. Deane Ida M. Mercer | Hopewell, N.Y. Walworth, N.Y. | Macedon, N.Y. Walworth, N.Y. | |
| Marriages by C.W. Lane | ||||
| 1886 Dec. 5 | Freeman J. Fulmer Anna M. Verbridge | Marion, N.Y. Marion, N.Y. | | |
| 1886 Dec. 26 | William Hinkle Katie Brantling | Fairville, N.Y. Newark, N.Y. | Lyons, N.Y. Arcadia, N.Y. | |
| 1887 Feb. 2 | Fred M. Taylor Carrie E. VanOstrand | Palmyra, N.Y. Arcadia, N.Y. | Palmyra, N.Y. Arcadia, N.Y. | |
| 1887 Dec. 18 | Nelson Tripp Ida May Longley | Marion, N.Y. E. Palmyra, N.Y. | Marion, N.Y. Canada | |
| 1888 Jan. 25 | Will Harris Evaline A. Stacy | Palmyra, N.Y. " " | Palmyra, N.Y. E. Palmyra, N.Y. | |
| 1888 Mar. 29 | Fred J. Growers Frankie M. Culver | Arcadia, N.Y. Palmyra, N.Y. | Aurelius, N.Y. Palmyra, N.Y. | |
| 1888 May 20 | William W. Campbell Jennie B. Green | " " E. Palmyra, N.Y. | Fishers, N.Y. E. Palmyra, N.Y. | |
| 1888 Apr. 6 | Herbert Starring Mary Robinson | Palmyra, N.Y. Canandaigua, N.Y. | Martinsburg Canandaigua, N.Y. | |
| 1888 Oct. 31 | Derius Fuller Jane A. Clum | Arcadia Newark | Columbia Co., N.Y. Arcadia, N.Y. | |
| 1888 Nov. 26 | Henry C. Hilimire Lizzie Cunningham | Seneca Falls, N.Y. E. Palmyra | Germany E. Palmyra | |
| 1889 Jan. 23 | Henry DeRight Lizzie McGee | Marion, N.Y. E. Palmyra | Williamson, N.Y. Arcadia | |
| 1889 Sept. 10 | Joseph C. Clinton Harriet E. Lown | E. Palmyra, N.Y. Marion, N.Y. | Dutchess Co., N.Y. Marbletown, N.Y. | |
| Marriages by A.J. Barltrap [Note: typewriter strike-over on "l"] | ||||
| 1890 May 15 | Edgar C. Hardy Emma Coulson | E. Palmyra, N.Y. Los Angeles, Calif. | Arcadia, N.Y. England | |
| Marriages by Elmer E. Smith | ||||
| 1891 Feb. 8 | Carlyle Moon Matie Engelson | Clyde, N.Y. E. Palmyra | Clyde N.Y. Palmyra | |
| 1891 Mar. 18 | Herbert Boekhout Carrie M. Tellier | E. Palmyra Arcadia | Arcadia Holland | |
| 1891 Aug. 23 | John Lowe Jr. Alice Rush | Palmyra, N.Y. " " | Lysander, N.Y. Palmyra, N.Y. | |
| 1891 Nov. 25 | Frank C. Hyman Susie Tellier | Newark, N.Y. Newark | Ontario, N.Y. Pickelville, Wayne Co. | |
| 1892 Feb. 8 | Reuben Henry Merton Daisy Van Norman | Marion, N.Y. Hydesville, N.Y. | Sittingbone, Eng. E. Palmyra, N.Y. | |
| 1891 July 15 | William Riley Alrever Hattie Newell Milton | Cicero, N.Y. Brewerton, N.Y. | Hastings, N.Y. Constantia, N.Y. | |
| 1892 Dec. 28 | Jacob O'Lier Libbie O'Meal | Palmyra, N.Y. E. Palmyra | Williamson, N.Y. E. Palmyra | |
| 1893 Jan. 2? 3? [Note: typewriter strikeover] | Fountain _. Wilson Alice A. McIntyre | Penn Yan, N.Y. " " | Virginia Arkwright, N.Y. | |
| 1893 Mar. 22 | Joseph A. DeFay Mary M. Tillier | Palmyra Arcadia | Hydesville E. Williamson, N.Y. | |
| 1893 May 1 | Thomas Snider Ella Maud Spence | Rochester, N.Y. " " | Belvin, Canada Oswego, N.Y. | |
| Marriages by D.W. Proseus | ||||
| 1894 Oct. 3 | William Hoff Ella L. [I.?] Stebbins | Arcadia " " | | |
| 1895 Aug. 15 | Herbert Johnson Minnie B. Ellsworth | Italy, N.Y. " " | Lambertville, N.J. Italy, N.Y. | |
| Marriages by Francis M. Smith | ||||
| 1897 Dec. 15 | Andrew J. Smith Eunice Myrtle Raymond | Reading Center, N.Y. " " | Jasper, Steuben Co. Reading, Schuyler Co., N.Y. | |
| 1898 Apr. 2 | Jerome N. Galloway Mary E. Forbes | Palmyra Clyde, N.Y. | Palmyra Rochester, N.Y. | |
| 1898 Oct. 8 | Harry E. Sanford Julia P.R. Lusk | Palmyra " " | Brockport, N.Y. Palmyra | |
| Marriages by J.B. Pitcher | ||||
| 1898 Sept. 17 | William Storr Sarah Morrison | Palmyra " " | Williamson, N.Y. Ontario | |
| 1899 Nov. 15 | Mortin S. Wage Mabel B.G. Cummings | Arcadia Ts. ["Ts." is the minister's abbreviation for "Township."] " " | Marion Brighton, Ont. Canada | |
| 1900 Feb. 11 | George Hibbard Mary Cook | Palmyra " " | Ts. Manchester | |
| 1900 Feb. 20 | William Mills Clara L. Kent | Arcadia Ts. E. Palmyra | | |
| 1900 Mar. 10 | Robert Noble Thomas Minnie Tellier | Arcadia Ts. Arcadia | St. Johns, New Brunswick Canda | |
| 1900 June 6 | John A. Clark Lulu May Green | Marion E. Palmyra | Newark E. Palmyra | |
| Marriages by A. Harroun | ||||
| 1902 Jan. 23 | David De Mell Katy Smith | Martville, Cayuga Co. N.Y. Newark | England | |
| 1902 Feb. 19 | George Isbell Martha J. Sherman | Onondaga, N.Y. Solvay, N.Y. | Onondaga Canada | |
| 1902 Sept. 4 | Louis Harden Hattie VanNorman | Newark, N.Y. " " | E. Palmyra | |
| Marriages by B.E. Pierce | ||||
| 1903 | Mr. Wage Jennie VerBridge | E. Palmyra " | ||
| 1903 Aug. | Burt Bavis Laura Staples | Palmyra " | Palmyra " | |
| Marriages by E.G. Evans | ||||
| 1906 Nov. 7 | Bartle DeCan Mary Blondell | Arcadia " " | Holland " " | |
| 1906 Nov. 28 | Henry DeCan Maude Ryckman | Arcadia " " | Marion | |
| 1907 Mar. 6 | Isaac Blondell Fidelia Golushia | Newark Newark | Holland Newark | |
| 1907 Mar. 20 | William Artlip 2nd Anna May Cook | Newark " " | Newark " " | |
| 1907 Aug. 15 | Clarence L. Halstead Lillian G. Tinney | Rushville, N.Y. Italy Hill, N.Y. | | |
Copied for Col. Wm. Prescott Chapt.
Dau. of the American Rev.
Newark, New York
by Mrs. Nellie T. Garlock
Port Gibson, N.Y.
Oct. 1939
DISCLAIMER: Confirmation of dates via other sources, before adding to your family records or placing into online databases as facts, is highly recommended. Some general questions about the records might be answered in the two introductory paragraphs at top of this page. For information about persons listed, or about this church, or availability of other records, we thank you in advance for directing ALL questions and research inquiries to the Office of the County Historian in Lyons, NY. If you have information to share on this page about any of the couples or ministers listed, please contact the site coordinators.
Back to Town of Palmyra Section
Back to Wayne County Vital Records Section