The Gilbert Family Picnic
Reunion on August 27, 1887
Click here to view the large scrolling image. 118 k.
A large picture of the Gilbert Family Picnic was contributed by Sally Malkowski, who is off line and contacted us about contributing
this photo. "There are about a 100 people in the photo, most residing in the Marion/Newark area. Some of the family's names
are Gilbert, Reed, Hope and Prentiss." Sally has been corresponding offline with Guy Prentiss and they've tentitively identified a
few people. If you can identify anyone in this photograph or have information to share, please contact Sally through
her daughter (who has email) and she will get in touch with Sally. It's very important that you
put "Gilbert Family Picnic" in the subject line so that it's not deleted.
"I received the beautiful photo from Guy Prentiss from California. He wrote and I quote that he
is "the spitting image" of a man in the photo standing by the window on left side. 2nd man from
left with mustache, young man. He is Guy's great-greatgrandfather named Guy Prentiss.
The tall man in the back rowwith the mustache, he believes to be Jefferson Sherman who
resided there. I personally believe that standing beside him is his wife, Delia Reed Sherman
[born 1835 or 1836 according to the Wayne County census]. Her gravestone from Marion
Cemetary states she was born 1834. They had six children:
Clara, married Wallace Moon of Rochester
Orin H., married Carolyn Isabel Beam
Charlotte who married Frank De Right
Bertha who married Thomas F. Young of Marion
Herbert and his sister May never married which leads me to believe that they are standing
at the left of their father, Jefferson Sherman. Because Jefferson's parents lived the next
farm north of him. My opinion, is that next to Delia is her mother-in-law Erminda Howell,
who married her cousin Zephaniah Sherman.
The teenage boy in the back row on the left side looks like my grandfather, Marshall McKee [born
October 27,1879 - January 22, 1956] but because he would be younger, the boy could be his older
brother Oliver Mc Kee [November 18,1873-July 20,1899].
The man standing in front of Oliver could be his father Hiram McKee. Hiram was born August 26,1846
and died April 3,1936. He enlisted in the 8th New York Calvary on August 3, 1863. He was at
Winchester, Cedar Creek when General Robert E. Lee surrendered ending the Civil War. Hiram received
wounds during the war, was captured, and taken prisoner at Cedar Creek, but told himself he
wasn't going to die in there. Another prisoner and he exchanged their home addresses by putting
it on a tiny piece of paper and placing it inside their boot; and during the night they climbed over
the wall and slid down the other side into the creek, swimming across and running for their life.
Hiram wrote twice to the other man's family but never heard from them, presuming that the
other man perhaps was unable to swim.
I have several 1900 photos of Hiram, of which he looks like the man at the picnic except that
he has pure white hair and the same shaped white beard.
Guy Prentice's great-great-great-grandmother is also in the picture. To find her is somewhat
harder to explain; in the front row there's the little boy with the straw hat, behind him is
the sober facedyoungster with a round hat on, behind him is a man with a large mustache, and
behind him is Rosannah Reed Prentiss, born in 1817. She married Martin Prentiss and had
seven children; Myron, Charles, George, Julia, Mary, James, and Rosadell. Their son George
was the only one of the siblings to change the spelling from Prentiss to Prentice; therefore Guy
is their offspring.
I made a copy from a book entitled "History of Ontario, New York" of a picture in it that has
James Prentiss and his grandson, James Prentiss."
Town of Marion Section
Family Bios Section
Copyright © 2001 - 2011 Sally Malkowski
Wayne County NYGenWeb
All Rights Reserved.